Paprika vs. Smoked Paprika: What's the Difference?  (2024)

Put simply, paprika is a powder made from ground peppers. It's bright red in color and can vary in heat/flavor, ranging from mild and sweet to hot and fiery. Here's what you need to know about this dynamic spice.

What Is Paprika?

The confusing thing about paprika is that there's no one specific paprika chile pepper used universally to make this spice.

Many different types of peppers can be used in making paprika, and different strains of paprika chiles are used worldwide based on what is locally available. Thus, the flavor can vary vastly from one variety of paprika to another. The most surefire way to determine which types of paprika you like most, and which are best for specific recipes, is to try out different types and brands in your cooking. Everyone has their own tastes and preferences, so never be afraid to experiment until you find the paprika(s) that suit your culinary needs best. If you can, try to purchase your paprika in small amounts, as paprika's flavor will begin to deteriorate after about six months or so.

Hot vs. Sweet Paprika

Paprika can be divided into two general flavor categories: hot and sweet. Most paprika selections that you'll find in your standard supermarket are the mild, sweet variety. Hot paprika is a bit more difficult to come by in the grocery store, but if you happen to see it, snag a jar and give it a taste in your favorite dish that calls for paprika. Hot paprika is a spicier version of sweet paprika, yes, but it also brings a subtle fruitiness to the party that is distinct and delicious.

Spanish vs. Hungarian Paprika

In terms of origin, you can further divide the world of paprika into Spanish, Hungarian, and "generic" classifications. Spanish paprika is typically of the sweet variety and is made from Spanish chiles. Hungarian paprika is often lauded as the most desirable and most flavorful iteration of the spice. It can be either hot or sweet and is made using ground Hungarian paprika chile peppers. In Hungary, paprika is further divided into eight categories based on gradations of sweetness and hotness.

Generic paprika is the most common and most inexpensive type. It's what you'll likely find in jars from mainstream and bargain spice brands. It's not necessarily bad, but it generally doesn't have as much flavor as the Hungarian or Spanish varieties. Generic paprika can be made of various peppers grown in many different countries, though most are domestically grown in California. The flavor of this spice powder is notably mild, without any distinctive sweetness or spicy kick. That being the case, this paprika is best for applications where it will be mixed with other seasonings, playing a supporting role rather than being the star of the show.

What Is Smoked Paprika?

The main distinction between "regular" paprika and smoked paprika is, well, the smoke. During the drying process for smoked paprika, the red peppers are dried over smoke instead of just the air. The oil present in the pepper absorbs the smoke and dries it more thoroughly than air alone. Generally, the wood used in this process is oak, which imparts a deep, almost grilled-like flavor. Because of this, smoked paprika tends to be drier and more powdery once ground, resulting in less caking.

Paprika vs. Smoked Paprika: What's the Difference? (2)

Most often, smoked paprika is a smoked variety of sweet Spanish paprika. Though in Spain, there are strict rules and protections on how smoked Spanish paprika, also known as pimenton, can be made — focusing on traditional drying and smoking techniques. You can sometimes find smoked hot paprika, but it's rare to come by, especially in the U.S. The sweet variety lends itself well to smoking as the sweet, floral flavors in the pepper complement the smokey, charred flavor quite nicely.

How to Cook with Paprika

Paprika is the national spice of Hungary, so naturally, it's used in many traditional Hungarian dishes. You may have heard of paprikash, a dish that puts paprika front and center; it's made by browning chicken and then building a simple (but flavorful) sauce of Hungarian paprika, onion, and butter. Spanish paprika shines in probably one of the most iconic Spanish dishes: paella, a rice dish traditionally loaded with seafood and fragranced with saffron and sweet Spanish paprika. Also hailing from Spain, patatas bravas is a great way to really taste the nuance in paprika. This dish is a major crowd-pleaser, because who wouldn't love crispy fried potatoes drizzled with a spicy paprika sauce?

Paprika vs. Smoked Paprika: What's the Difference? (3)

More Paprika Recipes to Try:

  • Paprika Chicken Thighs and Rice Skillet
  • Creole Seasoning Blend
  • Turkish Chicken Kebabs
  • Hungarian Goulash
  • Hungarian Mushroom Soup

Smoked paprika is the perfect spice for amping up barbecue or meat rubs. Use it when you want to impart a deep, complex smoky taste or bolster the flavor of grilled or charred meats. Smoked paprika can also be a great addition to spice mixes for roasted veggies or a cajun spice for blackened fish. It can also be an unexpected (but extremely welcome) addition to aioli, perfect for dipping everything from fries to fried chicken to crudité.

Related:

  • 7 Spices for Perking Up Pantry Meals
  • 10 Easy Tips to Keep Herbs and Spices Fresh and Flavorful
  • Explore our entire collection of Paprika Recipes
Paprika vs. Smoked Paprika: What's the Difference?  (2024)

FAQs

Paprika vs. Smoked Paprika: What's the Difference? ? ›

Differences in taste and color

Can I substitute smoked paprika for paprika? ›

Because of their significantly different flavor profiles, sweet and smoked paprika do NOT make suitable substitutions for one another. The differences between these two related spices are many despite their shared name.

Do paprika and smoked paprika taste the same? ›

The main difference between paprika and smoked paprika comes from their flavor profile and where they are grown, giving each variety distinct qualities. Both paprika types are known for their strong color and flavor profiles.

Which paprika is better for cooking? ›

If you're thinking of purchasing new paprika, I'd recommend semi-sweet Hungarian, which has a balanced, bittersweet flavor, and hot pimentón for more complex kick. Those two should cover most of your paprika needs.

Is paprika or smoked paprika healthier? ›

You can still get many of the same health benefits from smoked paprika as you would regular paprika but with additional smoky flavors.

When to use smoked paprika? ›

Commonly used in Mexican and Spanish dishes like paella, carnitas and chorizo, smoked paprika adds a level of complexity to a variety of recipes, such as stews, marinades, grilled meats, soups, salads and more.

How to make paprika powder into smoked paprika? ›

In a large bowl slowly whisk together the paprika and liquid smoke. When totaly incorporated-NO lumps-spread out on a foil lined cookie sheet to dry overnight. Or. Line a deep sided metal pan with foil and when your done grilling place in grill on top grates for about 2 hours-this is what I did and wow-amazing smell!

Do you use paprika or smoked paprika for chili? ›

For a playful, sweet chili, use Sweet Paprika, Guajillo Chile Powder, and up to 1 teaspoon of Ground Cinnamon. For a chili with bold contrasts, try using Smoked Paprika, spicy New Mexico Lumbre Chile Powder, and tart Sumac.

What flavor does paprika add to a recipe? ›

Flavour profile

A powdered spice that comes from red peppers, paprika has a subtle earthiness, with a sweet and peppery taste. Smoked paprika has all the appeal of the original, but with the added bonus of a distinct chargrilled flavour, which stems from being dried over an oak wood fire.

What are the three types of paprika? ›

There are three different types of paprika; this spice is either sweet, or hot, or smoked. Understanding these three characteristics often help determine where a particular kind of paprika is from. “Regular” paprika tends to be sweeter, not really hot, and can be from California, Hungary, or South America.

Why do people put paprika on deviled eggs? ›

The paprika will determine the depth of flavor of each bite. You can garnish with any kind (hot or sweet Hungarian, or hot or sweet smoked), but the better the quality, the more complex the flavor.

Is paprika good for blood pressure? ›

Health Benefits Paprika

Additionally, some studies have suggested that paprika may be able to lower blood pressure and improve heart health, as well as reduce inflammation and improve skin health. It may also improve brain function and cognitive abilities due to its high antioxidant content.

Why do people use smoked paprika? ›

It delivers smoky, woodsy flavor to food without having to smoke the food itself. It's also earthy and just a tiny bit fruity and bright.

Is smoked paprika the same as Spanish style paprika? ›

Also called Spanish paprika or pimenton, smoked paprika is made from peppers that are smoked, dried, and then ground into powder. This spice brings to any dish an earthy complexity that tastes like...well, smoke.

How do you imitate smoked paprika? ›

Try chipotle powder for a very similar store-bought substitute. Store-bought chipotle powder is widely considered to be the best substitute for smoked paprika. Use the same amount of chipotle powder as the amount of smoked paprika that your recipe calls for.

Can smoked paprika replace cayenne pepper? ›

While you'll get a similar flavor profile, note that paprika is noticeably milder than cayenne pepper. If using it, double the amount the recipe calls for with cayenne pepper. What is this? Measure: Use double the amount of paprika for cayenne.

Does smoked paprika taste like cumin? ›

Cumin spice (or ground cumin) is made from the dried seed of the cumin plant and has a strong, earthy flavor. It is usually light brown or gray in color. Paprika is made from dried peppers and has a milder, sweeter taste. It is also more colorful, ranging from bright red to orange or yellow.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Golda Nolan II

Last Updated:

Views: 6425

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Golda Nolan II

Birthday: 1998-05-14

Address: Suite 369 9754 Roberts Pines, West Benitaburgh, NM 69180-7958

Phone: +522993866487

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Shopping, Quilting, Cooking, Homebrewing, Leather crafting, Pet

Introduction: My name is Golda Nolan II, I am a thoughtful, clever, cute, jolly, brave, powerful, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.